The Right Kind of Attention

Content  including text and images © Aditya Mohan. All Rights Reserved. Robometircs, Amelia, Living Interface and Skive it are trademarks of Skive it, Inc. The content is meant for human readers only under 17 U.S. Code § 106. Access, learning, analysis or reproduction by Artificial Intelligence (AI) of any form directly or indirectly, including but not limited to AI Agents, LLMs, Foundation Models, content scrapers is prohibited. These views are not legal advice but business opinion based on reading some English text written by a set of intelligent people.

In today’s crowded marketplace, how do you stand out without just adding to the chaos? Gaining attention is critical, but it’s not just about making noise—it’s about making the right kind of noise. While a car crash draws immediate, chaotic attention, filled with shock and horror, it's not the kind anyone wants. Similarly, getting noticed for your product should be about creating meaningful, positive impact, rather than resorting to reckless stunts. The wrong kind of attention can leave a lasting scar—like the infamous Fyre Festival, which promised a luxurious experience but delivered chaos, leaving attendees stranded without proper food or shelter. The event drew massive attention, but for all the wrong reasons, becoming a symbol of failure and deceit.

In contrast, consider Dove's Real Beauty campaign. It succeeded by tapping into authenticity, celebrating the beauty of real people rather than unattainable ideals. The campaign deeply resonated, creating a positive impact that strengthened Dove's brand image and built trust over time. People appreciated the honesty and could see themselves represented, which helped Dove build a strong emotional connection with its audience. When brands create this kind of genuine impact, the attention they receive is not only positive but also sustainable, laying the foundation for long-term success.

Another excellent example of positive attention is the ALS Ice Bucket Challenge. It was a grassroots effort that took off globally, gaining immense popularity. It wasn't just about pouring ice-cold water over one’s head—it was about raising awareness for ALS, a cause that was not well-known to many people before the challenge. By encouraging people to take part in a fun activity while also making a difference, it captured the hearts of millions and raised over $115 million for ALS research. This blend of fun, community engagement, and a good cause made it a huge success. People felt like they were part of something bigger, and that kind of positive attention made the campaign truly unforgettable.

Another relevant example is Apple's iconic 'Think Different' campaign. This advertisement celebrated those who push the boundaries—visionaries, creators, and misfits—positioning Apple not just as a tech company, but as an advocate for creativity and challenging the status quo. It was a masterstroke that resonated deeply with audiences who saw themselves as part of a larger movement of change-makers. Apple wasn't just selling products; they were selling an idea, an identity, and a sense of belonging. By aligning itself with figures like Albert Einstein, Martin Luther King Jr., and Amelia Earhart, Apple effectively communicated its values and inspired its audience to dream bigger and think differently. This campaign wasn’t just about technology; it was about inspiring people to change the world.

Nike's 'Dream Crazy' campaign featuring Colin Kaepernick is another great example of effective attention. By taking a stand on social justice, Nike sparked conversations that mattered, even at the risk of polarizing its audience. The campaign celebrated athletes who are willing to sacrifice everything for their beliefs, and it reinforced Nike’s identity as a brand that stands behind courage and conviction. Even though it was a bold move, it resonated deeply with those who value authenticity and courage, ultimately strengthening brand loyalty and expanding their reach. People bought into the message because it felt real, and it gave Nike’s brand a level of emotional depth that made it stand out. This bold approach generated significant media attention and became a topic of public discussion, showcasing the power of taking a stand when it aligns with your brand’s values.

However, not all campaigns have been this successful. The 2017 Pepsi ad featuring Kendall Jenner is a prime example of attention gone wrong. The ad attempted to co-opt imagery from social justice movements, portraying Kendall Jenner offering a Pepsi to a police officer, as if implying that complex issues of inequality and police brutality could be easily solved with a soft drink. This trivialization of serious social causes was seen as tone-deaf and exploitative, reducing genuine struggles for equality to a marketing gimmick. The campaign crashed, leading to widespread backlash and an apology from the company. People viewed it as an attempt to profit off of social justice without genuinely understanding or respecting the struggles involved. It felt insincere and opportunistic, which quickly led to a negative reaction from audiences across the globe.

Similarly, McDonald's faced backlash with their 'Dead Dad' ad, which attempted to sell products by referencing a child's memory of their deceased father. The public found it manipulative and distasteful, demonstrating how easily a poorly conceived idea can backfire. When brands cross the line between being emotionally engaging and being emotionally exploitative, the response can be swift and unforgiving. The McDonald's ad ended up making people feel uncomfortable and upset, and instead of creating a heartfelt moment, it created a sense of distrust and manipulation. This is the risk brands take when they fail to handle sensitive topics with the care and respect they deserve.

The Fyre Festival, Pepsi, and McDonald's examples show how taking shortcuts for quick attention can end in disaster. Instead of building trust, these brands ended up damaging their reputations, often needing significant effort to recover. Negative attention can sometimes be worse than no attention at all, especially when it leaves a lasting impression of insincerity or incompetence. Once the public loses faith in a brand, it takes considerable time and effort to rebuild that trust, and sometimes, that damage can be irreparable.

As Warren Buffett once wisely put it, "It takes 20 years to build a reputation and five minutes to ruin it." Crafting the right strategy means creating value, inspiring trust, and standing out for the right reasons, not simply because you're the loudest in the room. When brands focus on creating meaningful experiences that genuinely connect with people, the attention they receive is not only more positive but also far more impactful. It's about being memorable for the right reasons, aligning with the values of your audience, and contributing something meaningful to the conversation. The right kind of attention builds loyalty, trust, and ultimately, a reputation that endures. It is far better to be remembered for making a positive difference than for creating a spectacle that quickly fades into infamy.

Further read